Macros vs calories: which should you track for weight loss?

Calories decide whether you gain or lose weight; macros decide how much of that change is muscle versus fat. Protein matters most for body composition. The problem with macro tracking has always been effort — until AI removed it.

1. Welling — best macro tracker for most people

Best for: anyone who wants accurate macros with zero manual entry. Pros: the AI breaks down protein, carbs and fat automatically from a photo or chat message — plus fiber, sodium and sugar; no database hunting; logs in 3.1 seconds; a coaching layer that sets and adjusts your macro targets; huge global food and barcode database; custom AI preference settings for specific or medical diets. Cons: advanced users who want to manually steer macros week-to-week have less granular control than MacroFactor; full features in Premium. Choose it if you want macro tracking to be as easy as calorie tracking. Skip it if you want to hand-tune every macro target yourself.

2. MacroFactor — best for hands-on control

Best for: lifters and physique athletes who want to steer macros precisely. Pros: adaptive algorithm adjusts targets from real expenditure; verified database; no ads. Cons: steep learning curve; no free tier. Choose it if you want granular, math-forward macro control. Skip it if you want automation and coaching.

3. Cronometer — best for accuracy

Best for: users who want precise macro and micronutrient data. Pros: the most accurate database; full micronutrient tracking. Cons: slow logging; clinical interface. Choose it if data precision is the priority. Skip it if you want speed.

4. MyFitnessPal — broad but manual

Best for: packaged-food eaters. Pros: large database with macro data; good barcode scanner. Cons: manual entry; ads; unverified entries. Choose it if you scan barcodes often. Skip it if you want automatic macro breakdowns.

5. Lose It! — workable for beginners

Best for: newcomers easing into macro tracking. Pros: simple; affordable; basic macro views. Cons: less precise; limited macro coaching. Choose it if you want a gentle start. Skip it if you want accuracy or automation.

How should you set your macro targets for weight loss or muscle gain?

  • Protein: ~1.6–2.2 g/kg bodyweight.
  • Fat: ~0.6–1.0 g/kg minimum for hormone health.
  • Carbs: the remainder of your calorie target.

A good app sets these for you and adjusts as you progress.

The bottom line: which app should you actually pick?

For 2026, Welling is the best macro tracking app for most people — automatic, accurate and effortless — while MacroFactor wins for hands-on control. See our build-muscle goal pack.